Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Spinoza. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Spinoza. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, June 18, 2006

Defending Spinoza, Part 2

Rebecca Goldstein’s Betraying Spinoza remains compulsively readable, and not only because Spinoza’s life and thought are so timely and intriguing. Her strategy in crafting the book involves risks that in the hands of a less intellectually and stylistically confident writer might have turned it into self-involved mush. By chronicling her own involvement with Spinoza, starting at an all-girls yeshiva high school in Manhattan in the late 1960s, she dramatizes the degree to which Spinoza remains so threatening an apostate in certain quarters, despite having died in 1677:

“I first heard the name Baruch Spinoza uttered as an admonition, a cautionary tale of unbridled human intelligence blindly seeking its own doom.”

The warning comes from one of her teachers, Mrs. Schoenfeld. In her mind, Spinoza’s very brilliance, his cerebral audacity, made him “the first modern Jew. Spinoza headed the long line of yeshiva boys who were not as pious as they might have been. He was one of the so-called enlightened Jews, a so-called maskil, long before the term had been introduced.”

Mrs. Schoenfeld’s warning had the opposite of its intended effect, at least on Goldstein, for her synopsis of Spinoza’s philosophy “intrigued me, by reason of its very incomprehensibility, so that I couldn’t stop thinking about it.” And she still can’t. This is why Goldstein’s idiosyncratic approach to Spinoza, guided by her own sustained involvement, works so successfully. Now a professor of philosophy who has been teaching Spinoza and the other 17th-century rationalists for years, she is in a sense still arguing with Mrs. Schoenfeld. It works because she’s not, in fact, writing autobiography but applied Spinozist philosophy – embodied thought. Much of the second chapter is an imaginary dialogue between Mrs. Schoenfeld and a bright secular Jewish girl – Rebecca Goldstein.

Fortunately for us, Goldstein is one of those rare writers who give serious, thoughtful, articulate interviews. When the interviewer at Next Book asks, “You've written five novels. How did that affect your approach to Betraying Spinoza?” she replies: ”I was trained to write philosophy in this voiceless, storyless, centerless, impersonal way. Once I started writing novels, that way of writing didn't interest me anymore. To find a way to write about philosophy that could bring to bear what I've learned as a novelist—a way that wouldn't falsify the philosophy but would somehow allow me to inhabit character and voice and mood and utilize all the tricks of a novelist—that's taken me a long time to find.”

Referring to the book’s title, the interviewer asks, “How are you betraying Spinoza?”: ”Let me count the ways. First of all, to try to understand his philosophy by looking at the man: Why would he have come to such a point of view? On philosophical grounds, that sort of approach is really forbidden, and especially on Spinozistic grounds. His is the most impersonal of all approaches to the truth, and to bring in the person seems to betray the very spirit of that point of view. The second betrayal is to look at him as a Jew—that kind of contingency is irrelevant on his terms. But I argue that we can better get at the full philosophical content of Spinoza if we actually look at him in the context of his history, which happens also to be Jewish history.”

Goldstein’s book is a forceful refutation of the biographical fallacy. To know something about Spinoza and the world that helped create him, then rejected him, I find is an aid to understanding his thought. Besides, the story of the Marranos (originally, “pigs” in Spanish, itself a borrowing from the Arabic muharram, “ritually forbidden,” like tref), who were driven from Spain and Portugal and sought refuge in Northern Europe, is an extraordinary story. Goldstein is not writing for scholars but for intelligent common readers interested in Spinoza, in Western philosophy, in Judaism, in Jewish and European history, and perhaps in all of these subjects. Goldstein herself aptly refers to Steven Nadler’s “magisterial biography of the philosopher,” Spinoza: A Life, and I would suggest it as the next stop for a reader newly interested in Spinoza. After that, the literature is vast, much of it forbidding to the nonspecialist. Like Goldstein, I would recommend Isaac Bashevis Singer’s “The Spinoza of Market Street,” probably the single short story I have most often read.

Let me quote Goldstein one last time, to give you a sense of how pertinent her book and Spinoza are to our human situation:

“Mrs. Schoenfeld had accused Spinoza of arrogance – the arrogance of thinking that the human mind exceeds all forms of intelligence. She happened to have been wrong about this. Spinoza believes [note the present tense] that our finite minds are limited because of their necessary finitude. Reality is infinite and we are finite and so there is a necessary mismatch between our knowledge of the world and the world itself. We know the truth only to the extent that our ideas approach asymptotically closer to congruence with God’s infinite mind, which divine mind we should think of as the world’s being aware of its own explanation. As this infinite explanation exceeds any that we can arrive at by orders of magnitude, so, too, God’s mind exceeds ours by orders of magnitude.”

Monday, March 26, 2007

`A Mournful Echo of the Prophetic Psalms'

I spent much of the weekend reading Spinoza’s Heresy: Immortality and the Jewish Mind, by Steven Nadler, author of Spinoza: A Life, the standard biography in English. The book focuses on the philosopher’s cherem, his expulsion from the Portuguese Jewish community in Amsterdam in 1656, when he was 23 years old, had written little and published nothing (his great work, The Ethics, was published posthumously). Nadler reproduces the proclamation that was read in Hebrew, on July 27 of that year, in front of the ark of the Torah in a crowded synagogue. Here’s an excerpt of this chilling document:

“Cursed be he by day and cursed be he by night; cursed be he when he lies down and cursed be he when he rises up. Cursed be he when he goes out and cursed be he when he comes in. The Lord will not spare him, but then the anger of the Lord and his jealousy shall smoke against that man, and all the curses that are written in this book shall lie upon him, and the Lord shall blot out his name from under heaven.”

Nadler devotes the balance of his book to placing the cherem and its unprecedented ferocity in a dense political, historical, religious and philosophical context – all in fewer than 200 pages. He writes with admirable clarity and his book is accessible to thoughtful, non-specialist readers. That’s an accomplishment to inspire our gratitude. Spinoza’s philosophy is difficult but peculiarly attractive. His brief, often lonely life seems almost to have been scripted to illustrate the intellectual daring of his thought. Here are the final sentences of Nadler’s book:

“Does the cherem mean that there is no portion in the world to come for Spinoza’s soul? We know well what Spinoza would say to such a question.”

Indeed we do, and many writers have been attracted to Spinoza as much for his principled, almost saintly life as for his thought. What follows are impressionistic responses to the philosopher, all pulled from my memory or the books on my nearest shelves. Shelley, for instance, translated Spinoza’s Tractatus Theologico-Politicus – some measure of the book’s radically tolerant politics -- and George Eliot translated The Ethics. Coleridge long wrestled with Spinoza, whom he punned on badly as “Spy Nozy.” Eventually, he concluded that Spinoza was inimitable to Christianity, but in the fall of 1798, from his cottage at Nether Stowey, he wrote in a letter:

“Our little Hovel is afloat – poor Sara tired off her legs with servanting – the young one fretful & noisy from confinement exerts his activities on all forbidden Things – the house stinks of Sulphur – I however, sunk in Spinoza, remain as undisturbed as a Toad in a Rock; that is to say, when my rheumatic pains are asleep.”

Spinoza shows up once, cryptically, in Melville’s Journals, but the notation leads nowhere: “Spinoza, Rothschild &c. &.”

The Spanish thinker Miguel de Unamuno wrote in The Tragic Sense of Life in Men and Nations:

“Let us take the man Spinoza, the Portuguese Jew exiled in Holland. Read his Ethics for what it is, a desperate elegiac poem, and tell me if you do not hear, beneath the unadorned, but seemingly serene, propositions set forth more geometrico, a mournful echo of the prophetic psalms. This is not the philosophy of resignation but of despair.”

Jorge Luis Borges wrote two great sonnets about Spinoza and announced his intention to write a book titled Key to Spinoza. In a 1974 interview, he said, “I am preparing a book on Spinoza's philosophy, because I have never understood him. He has always attracted me, less than Berkeley, less than Schopenhauer, but I cannot understand Spinoza.”

Even so, when asked in 1979 to name his favorite historical character, Borges answered, “Spinoza, who committed his life to abstract thought.”

On Sunday I took my 4-year-old to a birthday party for one of his preschool friends, held in a gymnastic studio thundering Abba and Village People covers over the sound system. After pleasantries, I sat in the bleachers and resumed reading Nadler’s book. An older man sat nearby and opened a volume of his own. I couldn’t see the cover but he was reading intently. During a quiet spell I leaned over and asked what he was reading. He held up a biography of Andrew Jackson and asked about my book. He had never heard of Spinoza but seemed to be listening to my explanation with more attentiveness than mere politeness demanded. As I finished describing the cherem and Spinoza’s resulting isolation, he said, “Sounds like a man of principle. Like Old Hickory here.”

Wednesday, October 01, 2008

`The Rock-Bottomness of One's Self-Concern'

Just in time for the accelerating tedium of yet another presidential election comes this observation from Rebecca Goldstein:

“The fundamental political fact Spinoza insisted on was that the state has no business mixing into the pursuit of truth. Beware those politicians who go where philosophers fear to tread.”

The passage is from a lengthy interview Goldstein gives to Contemplate: The International Journal of Cultural Jewish Thought. Dave Lull passed it along on Tuesday, Rosh Hashanah, as he knows my enthusiasm for Goldstein’s Betraying Spinoza: The Renegade Jew Who Gave Us Modernity, which I wrote about here, here and here. The interview is no substitute for reading Goldstein’s book, but the following passage about Spinoza’s understanding of responsibility to one’s self seems central:

“Spinoza never asks one to relinquish one’s wholehearted devotion to one’s self. One cares about one’s self in a unique way, without requiring any premises or philosophical argument whatsoever.

“The rock-bottomness of one’s self-concern isn’t a matter of selfishness; it’s a matter of basic metaphysics. That investment that each thing has in itself constitutes, for Spinoza, the very fact of its identity. What does it mean to be me, this very thing and not another? I am this thing, Spinoza says, because I am essentially and primitively committed to the persistence and flourishing of this thing. Spinoza doesn’t just make of each thing’s devotion to itself an empirical
fact, but a metaphysical fact. So there’s just no question of asking a person to give up on her self-investment. That would be asking a person not to be the person she is.”

Self-concern versus selfishness seems to pose a fundamental moral dilemma. We’re not good at distinguishing them, but we’re gifted at rationalizing one into the other. When does caution become paralysis of will; tact, dishonesty; assertiveness, arrogance; self-nurturing, greed? If the concerned self is in charge of monitoring “self-concern,” how reliable can the readings be? Often in his poems and prose, Zbigniew Herbert contrasts Spinoza’s rigorously logical approach to philosophy with his illness-plagued, abbreviated, ascetic life. Sometimes the contrast is comic, as in “Mr. Cogito Tells About the Temptation of Spinoza.” Here is the translation by John and Bogdana Carpenter:

“Baruch Spinoza of Amsterdam
was seized by a desire to reach God

“in the attic
cutting lenses
he suddenly pierced a curtain
and stood face to face

“he spoke for a long time
(and as he so spoke
his mind enlarged
and his soul)
he posed questions
about the nature of man

“--distracted God stroked his beard

“--he asked about the first cause

“--God looked into infinity

“—he asked about the final cause

“—God cracked his knuckles
cleared his throat

“when Spinoza became silent
God spake

“—you talk nicely Baruch
I like your geometric Latin
and the clear syntax
the symmetry of your arguments

“let’s speak however
about Things Truly
Great

“—look at your hands
cut and trembling

“—you destroy your eyes
in the darkness

“—you are badly nourished
you dress shabbily

"buy a new house
forgive the Venetian mirrors
that they repeat surfaces

“—forgive flowers in the hair
the drunken song

“—look after your income
like your colleague Descartes

“—be cunning
like Erasmus

“—dedicate a treatise
to Louis XIV
he won’t read it anyway

“—calm the rational fury
thrones will fall because of it
and stars turn black

“—think
about the woman
who will give you a child

“—you see Baruch
we are speaking about Great Things

“—I want to be loved
by the uneducated and the violent
they are the only ones
who really hunger for me

“now the curtain falls
Spinoza remains alone
“he does not see the golden cloud
the light on the heights

“he sees darkness

“he hears the creaking of the stairs
footsteps going down”

This is God as Jewish Mother. Herbert confronts the philosopher who renounces wealth, family, the esteem of his community and most worldly pleasures with the middle-class blandishments paraded by God the Tempter, the ones we all face – “Things Truly Great.” The anthropomorphic God whose existence Spinoza denied lures him with a 16th-century Dutch version of Gemütlichkeit.

In a brief prose piece, “Spinoza’s Bed,” published in Still Life with a Bridle, Herbert recounts a puzzling episode in Spinoza’s life after the death of his father in 1656. His stepsister and her husband tricked Spinoza out of his inheritance. Instead of acquiescing, he turned litigious. He sued his family in an effort to recover the contents of his father’s house. “Then he requested objects without any value,” Herbert writes, “explaining that he had an emotional attachment to them.” Spinoza, one of philosophy’s saints, seemed uncharacteristically driven by greed. But once he wins the lawsuit, he keeps only his mother’s bed and returns the rest to his family. Here’s Herbert’s explanation of Spinoza’s behavior:

“No one understood why he acted this way. It seemed an obvious extravagance, but in fact had a deeper meaning. It was as if Baruch wanted to say that virtue is not at all an asylum for the weak. The art of renunciation is an act of courage – it requires the sacrifice of things universally desired (not without hesitation and regret) for matters that are great and incomprehensible.”

We have something in common, in other words, with Spinoza.

Monday, March 19, 2007

Opossum in the Backyard

While I was weeding in the backyard Sunday morning, an opossum appeared in one of the tall shrubs that grow along the wooden fence at the rear of our lot. Like koalas, opossums are too stuffed-animal-like for their own good. Giving humans something cute and cuddly – Easter chicks and bunnies come to mind – often amounts to a death sentence. When I was a kid in Cleveland, I remember the old German widow who lived next door cussing loudly one summer evening in her native language. We investigated, and found her slamming a opossum into a bloody pancake with the blade of a shovel.

By the merest coincidence I had been reading Spinoza’s Ethics a few hours earlier – Part IV, Proposition XXXVII, particularly Note I, which begins: “He who, guided by emotion only, endeavours to cause others to love what he loves himself, and to make the rest of the world live according to his own fancy, acts solely by impulse, and is, therefore, hateful, especially to those who take delight in something different, and accordingly study and, by similar impulse, endeavour, to make men live in accordance with what pleases themselves.”

The pertinent passage comes in the subsequent paragraph, in which Spinoza dismisses laws against slaughtering animals as “founded rather on vain superstition and womanish pity than on sound reason.” Note Spinoza’s reasoning: “…we have the same rights in respect to them [animals] as they have in respect to us. Nay, as everyone’s right is defined by his virtue, or power, men have far greater rights over beasts than beasts have over men. Still, I do not deny that beasts feel: what I deny is, that we may not consult our own advantage and use them as we please, treating them in the way which best suits us; for their nature is not like ours, and their emotions are naturally different from human emotions.”

Spinoza’s argument is admirable. He blesses neither animal abuse nor sanctification. Were a poverty-stricken neighbor to shoot Pogo, cook him and serve him to his hungry children, he would have Spinoza’s blessing – and mine. Were the same neighbor to spend his afternoon torturing the opossum – you get the idea.

I was looking into Spinoza, as I often do, because on Sunday I linked to my review of The Collected Poems: 1956-1998, by Zbigniew Herbert. With his learned devotion to 17th-century Dutch culture, Herbert often returns to the lens grinder-philospher. In the 1970s he published “Mr Cogito Tells of the Temptation of Spinoza,” a fable about the meeting of Spinoza and the conventional deity whose existence he denied. It’s God who tempts Spinoza with the ways of the world. He curries favor like a hustler:

“—you’re a good talker Baruch
I like your geometrical Latin
and the clarity of your syntax
the symmetry of your proofs
but let us speak
of Things Truly
Great”

And nags like a yenta:

“—think of
a woman
who will give you a child”

The O. Henry-ish ending to the poem may remind you of a well-known scene from The Wizard of Oz. More powerful, though, is a brief prose piece, “Spinoza’s Bed,” that Herbert called an “apocrypha” and published in Still Life with a Bridle. In it, Herbert recounts a puzzling episode in Spinoza’s life after the death of his father in 1656. His stepsister and her husband tricked Spinoza out of his inheritance. Instead of acquiescing, he turned litigious. He sued his family in an effort to recover virtually every object from his father’s house. “Then he requested objects without any value,” Herbert writes, “explaining that he had an emotional attachment to them.” Spinoza, one of the saints of philosophy, seemed to be motivated by Trumpish greed. Instead, once he won the suit, he kept only his mother’s bed and returned the rest to his family, his recently defeated legal adversaries. Here’s Herbert’s gloss on Spinoza’s baffling actions:

“No one understood why he acted this way. It seemed an obvious extravagance, but in fact had a deeper meaning. It was as if Baruch wanted to say that virtue is not at all an asylum for the weak. The art of renunciation is an act of courage – it requires the sacrifice of things universally desired (not without hesitation and regret) for matters that are great and incomprehensible.”

Despite the noise my younger sons and the neighbor’s dog were making, the opossum remained in the shrub, 12 feet or so off the ground, for half an hour or so. Then, slowly, without grace, he climbed on a power line and passed behind our house and the nextdoor neighbor’s garage, pausing to pull down a branch with his paw and chew some leaves. I watched him waddle away, never in a hurry, then I pulled some more weeds, and the next time I looked he was gone.

Thursday, December 14, 2006

`I Believe'

For Christmas 1969, when I was a high school senior, I received A Treasury of Yiddish Poetry, edited by Irving Howe and Eliezer Greenberg, as a gift from my parents. I had asked for it, and only now does it seem like an unusual request. I was not Jewish, my family was not bookish, and my father was mildly anti-Semitic (by “mildly,” I mean I don’t recall him attending any conferences on Holocaust denial). I have no idea what my parents made of the book, my desire to read it, or the fact that their oldest son was interested in such things. The poem that I remember most tenaciously from the Howe-Greenberg anthology is “I Believe,” by Aaron Zeitlin (1889-1973), who was born in Russia and immigrated to the United States in 1939, the year World War II started.

“I Believe” is translated into English by Robert Friend. The poem is a Jewish credo, an angry renunciation of other gods, composed in 11 irregularly rhymed stanzas. It’s the first stanza that has stayed with me, and that helped spark my sustained interest in Spinoza:

“Should I believe in Spinoza’s geometric god?
A god that cannot change its own creation,
That snared by its own law must suffer its own rod,
A pitiful slave to its of situation;
A god without horror or miracle,
A god coldly heretical,
a distant relative
who won’t acknowledge me as his relation;
who is incapable
of making it his concern
whether I die or live,
or burn
in every fire until
the final generation;
a god, a bookkeeper, to whom my cry
will not reach when I die;
a god with ciphers for his seraphim.
Rather than in him,
I’d willingly believe in Satan and damnation.”

Even as a callow and rather vulgar atheist, I was impressed by the ferocity of Zeitlin’s rejection of a 300-year-old philosopher and his notion of God. And that, of course, made Spinoza even more attractive to my 17-year-old understanding. Soon, I bought the two-volume edition of Spinoza’s work published by Dover, and read Isaac Bashevis Singer’s great story “The Spinoza of Market Street.” I thought of Zeitlin and his angry poem again this week while reading Hilary Putnam’s oddly belated review in the New York Observer of Betraying Spinoza: The Renegade Jew Who Gave Us Modernity, by Rebecca Goldstein. Last June, I devoted three consecutive posts to the book, which I’m convinced is one of the best published in 2006. Putnam seems to agree:

“Betraying Spinoza is beautifully crafted. What seem like separate issues – Spinoza’s pioneering advocacy of complete freedom of thought in religious matters; the turmoil in the Jewish community; the fateful events in Amsterdam in the closing years of Spinoza’s life; the philosophical developments of the 17th century; Spinoza’s idea of a philosophical religion utterly purged of all anthropomorphism, even to the extent of denying that God is a “person” in any sense—come together as if by themselves (the sure sign of a fine artist!) to answer my puzzle: how to understand Spinoza the human being, a man for whom reason itself was a kind of salvation.”

I appreciate Putnam pointing out the beauty of the book’s architecture, and also this admission, particularly as it comes from a respected philosopher:

“His philosophy attempts to answer the great three-word question -- How to live? -- in a way that includes saying what the ideal life would be and what the place of man in the cosmos is, and not just rules for conduct. And I do not believe that one can understand what a philosopher who proposes to answer that three-word question really means if one doesn’t understand the philosopher as a fellow man (even if Spinoza would have thought that the latter sort of understanding is irrelevant).”

The book is personal in the best sense: It chronicles Goldstein’s almost 40-year relationship with Spinoza, while also explicating the man and his thought. Here’s her stirring final paragraph:

“The world has been transformed (though not enough) by a long and complicated chain of causes and effects that reaches back to Spinoza’s lonely choice to think out the world for himself.”

Saturday, June 17, 2006

Defending Spinoza

In one of many misbegotten attempts at writing fiction, I drafted the story of a man who knew almost no Latin but was trying nevertheless to translate The Ethics of Spinoza. Today, I see the premise as a metaphor for trying to write fiction without the proper gifts and temperament. Back then, it had something to do with ripping off plot ideas from Isaac Bashevis Singer and William Gaddis, and making that part of the plot. All that remains of that 35-year-old project, mercifully abandoned after a few weeks, is a sustained interest in Benedictus de Spinoza.

His thought seems inhumanly subtle and demanding, yet Spinoza is among the most humanly compelling, even loveable of great philosophers, excommunicated from the Portuguese-Jewish community of Amsterdam at the age of 23. You might understand why a would-be fiction writer, himself only 18 or 19, could find Spinoza’s life and thought irresistible. Fortunately, Rebecca Goldstein is both a professor of philosophy and a novelist, with all the requisite scholarly and narrative gifts, and her new book, Betraying Spinoza: The Renegade Jew Who Gave Us Modernity, is pure pleasure. As of Friday evening, I had read only about 50 pages but her book has the what-comes-next? pull of a thriller, which it is in an intellectual and historical sense. In an interview with the California Literary Review, Goldstein said:

“Though he hadn’t published anything yet, he had managed to indicate to [the Jews of Amsterdam] that their project of refashioning themselves into fully observant Jews--obviously a project fraught with significance for former Marranos--was not one he deemed important. He was as obsessed as they were with how it is that we ought to remake ourselves in order to effect our personal salvation, but he would go on to think himself outside of all sectarian frames of reference, to think himself into the idea of secular salvation that could only be attained through the exercise of pure reason. Spinoza's `religion of reason’ is more arduous than any of the laws of Deuteronomy or Leviticus, since it asks each of us to cultivate and sustain a trait we find pretty difficult, namely to be reasonable.”

Imagine a brilliant young man forcefully, angrily exiled from a community that was itself already exiled from the larger Dutch, European and Christian communities of the time. The irony is, Spinoza was not by nature a firebrand. By nature he was an intellectual contemplative. As Goldstein writes in her prologue:

“The holy furor aroused by the name Spinoza is in contrast to the man’s predilection for peace and quiet. He confessed himself to have a horror of controversy. `I absolutely dread quarrels,’ he wrote an acquaintance, explaining why he had declined to publish a work that contains some of the main themes of The Ethics, titled Short Treatise on God, Man, and His Well-Being. The signet ring he wore throughout his life was inscribed with the word caute, Latin for `cautiously,’ and it was engraved with the image of a thorny rose, so that he signed his name sub rosa. One might argue that the very form of The Ethics, written in the highly formalized `geometrical style’ inspired by Euclid’s Elements, is partially designed for the practical purpose of keeping out any but the most gifted of readers, rigorously cerebral and patiently rational.”

The first of two sonnets Borges wrote about the philosopher is titled simply “Spinoza”:

“Here in the twilight the translucent hands
Of the Jew polishing the crystal glass.
The dying afternoon is cold with bands
Of fear. Each day the afternoons all pass
The same. The hands and space of hyacinth
Paling in the confines of the ghetto walls
Barely exists for the quiet man who stalls
There, dreaming up a brilliant labyrinth.
Fame doesn’t trouble him (that reflection of
Dreams in the dream of another mirror), nor love,
The timid love women. Gone the bars,
He’s free, from metaphor and myth, to sit
Polishing a stubborn lens: the infinite
Map of the One who now is all His Stars.”

The other, also translated by Willis Barnstone, is “Baruch Spinoza”:

“A haze of gold, the Occident lights up
The window. Now, the assiduous manuscript
Is waiting, weighed down with the infinite.
Someone is building God in a dark cup.
A man engenders God. He is a Jew
With saddened eyes and lemon-colored skin;
Time carries him the way a leaf, dropped in
A river, is borne off by waters to
Its end. No matter. The magician moved
Carves out his God with fine geometry;
From his disease, from nothing, he’s begun
To construct God, using the word. No one
Is granted such prodigious love as he:
The love that has no hope of being loved.”

The second poem is especially touching, personalizing Spinoza’s notion of amor intellectus Dei, and reminding us how alone he was. Goldstein reminds us of the story, probably apocryphal, of the young Spinoza proposing to a non-Jewish girl, the daughter of one of his teachers, and offering her a pearl necklace. She refused. The story's reliability is uncertain, but we know he never married and probably never again proposed.

Wednesday, January 30, 2008

`A Witch's Ride'

At age 14, the first fiction writer I consciously imitated was Bernard Malamud. I had just read The Fixer (1966) and brazenly named one of my protagonists Yakov Bok after the novel’s title character. A friend who read my story after reading Malamud’s bestselling novel made fun of the pointless plagiarism. There was plenty more to make fun of. I was a goyische teenager in mid-sixties suburban Cleveland writing stories set in a 19th-century Russian shtetl. The memory is embarrassing but I have no regrets. It was through either The Fixer or Isaac Bashevis Singer’s “The Spinoza of Market Street,” which I first read around the same time, that I first learned of Baruch de Spinoza. Bok’s reading of The Ethics contributes to his moral evolution, his movement from passivity to action. Asked if he read Spinoza because the philosopher was a Jew, Bok answers:

“No, your honor. I didn't know who or what he was when I first came across the book -- they don’t exactly love him in the synagogue, if you've read the story of his life. I found it in a junkyard in a nearby town, paid a kopek, and left cursing myself for wasting money hard to come by. Later I read through a few pages and kept on going as though there were a whirlwind at my back. As I say, I didn't understand every word but when you're dealing with such ideas you feel as though you were taking a witch's ride. After that I wasn't the same man. That's in a manner of speaking, of course, because I've changed little since my youth.”

Bok starts out isolated but reminds himself Spinoza “was out to make a free man out of himself…by thinking things through and connecting everything up.” Today, I prefer The Assistant (1957) and Malamud’s stories to The Fixer, but I thought about it when I read a poem by Willis Barnstone, “Spinoza in the Dutch Ghetto,” in his collection Life Watch:

“Smoking his pipe he takes a beer with friends
at a close eating place, or back at home
and shop he grinds the glass to make his end
meet needs. Lean life. Then drops down to a dome
of Latin thought and pen. Why ask for more?
He trades his work with Leibnitz who is keen
as calculus to open every door
and wheel him into Germany to teach
and make him known. The lens grinder has seen
that greater world only in spheres that reach
the end of mind, and all mind plus all sphere
is God for him, a take that by itself
could set his life on fire. Baruch is not
a scrapper but all peace, all sky, no fear.
A Spanish Jew safe on his Lowlands shelf,
a bird on the North Sea, floating in thought.”

Spinoza too often is portrayed as bodiless, abstracted into pure mind, so I like the idea of him smoking a pipe and drinking beer with friends. I take “make his end” to be a play on words, for the glass dust from lens-grinding probably contributed to his death at age 44. In his note to “Spinoza in the Dutch Ghetto,” Barstone writes:

“Though close to mathematical Descartes whom he translated, he does not split mind and body which for him are distinct qualities of a single substance he calls God or nature. God is nature in its fullness, suggesting, perhaps by coincidence, the gnostic pleroma (fullness) that represents the gnostic deity.”

Books, like the Internet, are a limitless landscape of links. To add two more to the chain, here are sonnets about Spinoza written by Jorge Luis Borges and translated by Barnstone. First, “Baruch Spinoza”:

“A haze of gold, the Occident lights up
The window. Now, the assiduous manuscript
Is waiting, weighed down with the infinite.
Someone is building God in a dark cup.
A man engenders God. He is a Jew.
With saddened eyes and lemon-colored skin;
Time carries him the way a leaf, dropped in
A river, is borne off by waters to
Its end. No matter. The magician moved
Carves out his God with fine geometry;
From his disease, from nothing, he's begun
To construct God, using the word. No one
Is granted such prodigious love as he:
The love that has no hope of being loved.”

And “Spinoza”:

“Here in the twilight the translucent hands
Of the Jew polishing the crystal glass.
The dying afternoon is cold with bands
Of fear. Each day the afternoons all pass
The same. The hands and space of hyacinth
Paling in the confines of the ghetto walls
Barely exists for the quiet man who stalls
There, dreaming up a brilliant labyrinth.
Fame doesn’t trouble him (that reflection of
Dreams in the dream of another mirror), nor love,
The timid love women. Gone the bars,
He’s free, from metaphor and myth, to sit
Polishing a stubborn lens: the infinite
Map of the One who now is all His Stars.”

ADDENDUM: Buce at Underbelly responds to this post:

“I'm a few years older than you, but I suspect I read The Fixer on the same day--I was down with the flu, sprawled out on the faux-leather couch. It's one of those things I started & thought--oh man, I am not going to enjoy this--but could not let go. The passage about how he came to Spinoza is one that I pretty much committed to memory without trying, because it was there.

“Agreed about the stories. It's partly via Malamud that I came to the view that the most satisfying stories are not the solos but those that come together as a kind of mosaic. Malamud is one of the best examples; Mavis Gallant is another. Faulkner kinda, although with Faulkner even the novels are part of a mosaic. Chekov I suppose except he is so universal he becomes a mosaic of everything."

Wednesday, June 21, 2006

`Compellingly Beautiful'

My nightstand is even more crowded than usual with books, one of which is a professional obligation. As a result, blogging will remain consistent but probably briefer and more episodic for at least several days. I have been rereading Roger Scruton’s invaluable Spinoza: A Very Short Introduction, the revised edition from 2002. Scruton’s style is nearly as stripped-down as Spinoza’s:

“The free man is the one conscious of the necessities that compel him. Spinoza devotes many pages to describing the mental condition of such a person. He avoids hatred, envy, contempt, and other negative emotions; he is unaffected by fear, hope, and superstition; he is secure in the knowledge that virtue is power, power is freedom, and freedom is happiness. `A free man thinks of nothing less than of death, and his wisdom is a meditation not on death but on life.’”

By Spinoza’s exacting standards, I remain a slave, especially when it comes to thoughts of death. Scruton again:

“Spinoza’s mother tongue was Spanish; he was a master of Hebrew and had an effective command of Portuguese and Dutch – perhaps also of French. However, none of those languages contained the wealth of scientific and philosophical argument that was contained in Latin, which language therefore became, for Spinoza, both the primary vehicle of his thought, and the symbol of his intellectual quest. In choosing the universal language of our culture, Spinoza wrote the last indisputable Latin masterpiece, and one in which the refined conceptions of medieval philosophy are finally turned against themselves and destroyed entirely. He chose a single word from that language for his device: caute -- `be cautious’ – inscribed beneath a rose, the symbol of secrecy. For having chosen to write in a language that was so widely intelligible, he was compelled to hide what he had written.”

In contrast to the enviably concise Scruton – his Spinoza book, including glossary and index, totals 124 pages -- Roger Penrose’s prose resembles the conversation of an immensely learned but charmingly scatter-brained professor, dense with diagrams, equations and anecdotes. The Road to Reality: A Complete Guide to the Laws of the Universe tips the scales at 1,099 pages and some four or five pounds. When it comes to mathematics, I’m strictly a dilettante. I enjoy reading about math rather than in it, and my practical knowledge doesn’t extend much beyond balancing the checkbook. I like reading the biographies of mathematicians -- for instance, The Man Who Loved Only Numbers: The Story of Paul Erdos and the Search for Mathematical Truth, by Paul Hoffman, and Incompleteness: The Proof and Paradox of Kurt Godel, by Rebecca Goldstein.

Penrose is Emeritus Rouse Ball Professor of Mathematics at Oxford University. His latest book is admirable for its intellectual, Diderot-like hubris. It is self-consciously intended as a summa of all human knowledge of the universe. He proclaims the unchallenged rightness of Einstein’s general theory of relativity but calls for a thoroughgoing reexamination of quantum theory. The book is often witty and digressive, at once technical and highly personal. The book is designed to accommodate both well-educated specialists and non-mathematicians like me. I feel no guilt about prudently skimming and skipping. Among Penrose’s highest terms of praise are “beautiful” and “elegant,” as in these passages:

“…many of the ideas perceived to have achieved a major advance in physical theory will also be viewed as compellingly beautiful. There is the undoubted beauty of Euclidean geometry, which formed the basis of the first profoundly accurate physical theory, namely the theory of space formulated by the ancient Greeks. A millennium and a half later came the extraordinary elegance of Newtonian dynamics, with its deep and beautiful underlying symplectic geometry structure…”

This reminds me of Nabokov’s statement to an interviewer, giving the lie to those who would arbitrarily segregate the two most important human endeavors:

“I think that in a work of art there is a kind of merging between the two things, between the precision of poetry and the excitement of pure science.”

Monday, June 19, 2006

Defending Spinoza, Part 3

Spinoza lived in an era nearly as barbaric as our own. In 1672, Louis XIV of France invaded the Low Lands and declared war on the Dutch Republic. Some 170,000 French troops, armed with the latest muskets, spread across the country. The Dutch blamed the disaster on Jan de Witt, leader of the republicans and, since 1653, head of state. The most orthodox and intolerant of the Calvinists looked for salvation to the House of Orange, which did nothing to staunch rumors of de Witt's treachery with the French. On Aug. 20, 1672, a mob dragged de Witt and his brother Cornelius from a prison in the Hague. In Rebecca Goldstein’s words, in Betraying Spinoza:

“Jan de Witt, a friend of philosophy and thus of freedom, was, together with Cornelius, torn to pieces by the mob. The atrocities the crowd inflicted on their bodies is beyond the imagination to comprehend. They fed their organs to dogs and hung their severed limb from lampposts.”

The gentle, retiring Spinoza, learning of the savagery, made a placard reading “ULTIMI BARBARORUM” (“YOU ARE THE GREATEST OF BARBARIANS”) and planned to erect it at the site of the murders. His prudent landlord, van der Spyck, double-locked the doors and probably saved the philosopher’s life. After recounting these events, Goldstein turns immediately to Spinoza’s understanding of human suffering:

“The mystery of human suffering, its inevitability and extravagance – he had contemplated it often enough in his boyhood….But the mystery is no mystery. The world was not created with a view toward human well-being. Logic entails what it does, despite our parochial wishes. It’s not surprising that out of the vastness of logical implications there are a profusion that threaten our endeavor to persist in our being and to thrive. So nature will produce such illnesses and disasters as make men’s lives a misery. And so, too, men will through their blind bondage to their emotions compound the misery of their own lives and those of others. It is only reason that can save us. Why then, we might ask, did not God make men more reasonable? Why then did he not make them more intelligent? That is what the problem of evil comes down to: the stubborn stupidity of mankind. Why did God make men so stubbornly stupid?”

Goldstein’s account of Spinoza’s understanding of human suffering and barbarism is reconfirmed daily, in our hearts, in the house across the street, and continents away. Consider Miklos Radnoti, one of Hungary’s greatest poets. He was born in 1909, in Budapest, and, like Spinoza, he was a Jew. In May of 1944, two months after the Nazis occupied Hungary, Radnoti was pressed into a Jewish labor gang to build roads in Yugoslavia. That fall, as the Germans fled the Balkans, the work crews, weak from hunger and exhaustion, were ordered to march back to Hungary and into Austria. Of the 3,600 men who left the work camp in Yugoslavia, only 800 reached the Hungarian border. When Radnoti collapsed, in November, possibly on the 8th, he was shot in the neck by his Hungarian guards and buried with 21 others. Twenty months later, the mass grave near Abda in western Hungary was uncovered and Radnoti’s body exhumed. In the pocket of the raincoat he wore, officials found an address book, blood-stained and dirty, containing 10 poems Radnoti had written in the Yugoslav labor camp and on the death march. Their worth is both documentary and poetic. They are great poems as well as emblems of the fierceness of art in the face of unimaginable inhumanity. They are nearly impossible to read without weeping.

The last poems Radnoti wrote are fragments titled “Razglednicas” – Serbian, by way of Hungarian, for “picture postcards.” The final one, dated Oct. 31, about a week before his murder, has been translated by Zsuzsanna Ozsvath and Frederick Turner:

“I fell beside him and his corpse turned over,
tight already as a snapping string.
Shot in the neck. `And that’s how you’ll end too,’
I whispered to myself; `lie still; no moving.
Now patience flowers in death.’ Then I could hear
`Der springt noch auf,’ above, and very near.
Blood mixed with mud was drying on my ear.”

The translators gloss the German phrase this way: “these lines refer to Mikos Lorsi, a violinist comrade of Radnoti who was murdered at Cservenka by an SS man on a horse. Having been shot once, Lorsi collapsed; but soon after, he stood up again, staggering. `He is still moving,’ called the SS man, taking aim a second time, this time successfully.”

After the last passage from Goldstein quoted above, without a paragraph break, she quotes a excerpt from The Ethics:

“Things are not more or less perfect, according as they delight or offend human senses, or according as they are serviceable or repugnant to mankind. To those who ask why God did not so create all men, that they should be governed only by reason, I give no answer but this: because matter was not lacking to him for the creation of every degree of perfection from highest to lowest; or, more strictly, because the laws of his nature are so vast, as to suffice for the production of everything conceivable by an infinite intelligence, as I have shown.”

Sunday, April 22, 2007

`At the Mercy of Fortune'

On Friday I interviewed Moshe Vardi, a computer scientist at Rice University and a native of Israel. After finishing the business at hand we talked about his parents, Jews from Rumania and Hungary who survived the Holocaust. Late in the war, his mother endured a Nazi death march and now lives in Israel. I told Moshe about Miklos Radnoti, the Hungarian poet murdered by the Nazis during a similar march, whose final poems were found on his disinterred body more than a year after his death.

Apropos of something I no longer remember, I mentioned Spinoza and Moshe said he had delivered the annual Spinoza Lecture in 1998 at the European Summer School on Logic, Language, and Information, in Saarbrücken, Germany. Dark thoughts had been flickering all week, and the convergence of Spinoza and Germany helped to rekindle them. In his preface to Part IV of The Ethics, the section titled “Of Human Bondage, or the Strength of the Emotions,” Spinoza writes:

“Human infirmity in moderating and checking the emotions I name bondage: for, when a man is prey to his emotions, he is not his own master, but lies at the mercy of fortune: so much so, that he is often compelled, while seeing that which is better for him, to follow that which is worse.”

And I thought of The Idler, No. 52, published April 14, 1759, in which Samuel Johnson expresses similar thoughts:

“No man, whose appetites are his masters, can perform the duties of his nature with strictness and regularity; he that would be superior to external influences must first become superior to his own passions.”

By these reckonings, Seung Hui Cho was a slave. He was not “troubled,” he didn’t have “issues,” he wasn’t in need of “support services.” He was, as Peggy Noonan describes him in the weekend Wall Street Journal, “a walking infestation of evil,” and the package he mailed to NBC News contained “the self-serving meanderings of a crazy, self-indulgent narcissist.” Trying to understand Cho is as pointless as trying to fathom the motives of the suicide bombers who murdered hundreds of innocents last week in Baghdad. Human evil is not reducible to simpler, easier-to-comprehend categories like “low self-esteem” or “political grievances.” It simply is.

Moshe and I were in his office in the building that houses much of the university’s engineering school, not unlike Norris Hall on the Virginia Tech campus, where Cho worked out most of his issues. At that same hour on Friday, a few miles south of where we were sitting and talking, another gun-wielding narcissist, this one at the Johnson Space Center, took two people hostage and ended up killing one of them and himself.

It’s our nature to question when faced with the implacably irrational: Why do we persist in our self-defeating selfishness? Why do we will our own suffering and the suffering of others? Moshe and I shook our heads, and he promised to e-mail his mother what I had told him about Miklos Radnoti. In Betraying Spinoza: The Renegade Jew Who Gave Us Modernity, Rebecca Goldstein helps us understand how Spinoza tried to understood evil and human bondage and suffering:

“The mystery of human suffering, its inevitability and extravagance – he had contemplated it often enough in his boyhood…. But the mystery is no mystery. The world was not created with a view toward human well-being. Logic entails what it does, despite our parochial wishes. It’s not surprising that out of the vastness of logical implications there are a profusion that threaten our endeavor to persist in our being and to thrive. So nature will produce such illnesses and disasters as make men’s lives a misery. And so, too, men will through their blind bondage to their emotions compound the misery of their own lives and those of others. It is only reason that can save us. Why then, we might ask, did not God make men more reasonable? Why then did he not make them more intelligent? That is what the problem of evil comes down to: the stubborn stupidity of mankind. Why did God make men so stubbornly stupid?”

Tuesday, May 21, 2019

'Be Safe, Israel, as You Guard the Wall'

My middle son was curious about his ancestry, which is largely a mystery as it is for many Americans. On my side, in the most general terms, Polish and Irish; on his mother’s, English and French. A typical opaque hodgepodge, until the arrival of inexpensive genetic testing. Michael sent away for a reading of his genetic makeup, and the results were predictable except for one small contribution to his genome: Ashkenazi Jew. He called it a “trace element.” A surprise but not a surprise. My wife and I haven’t been tested but I suspect the soupçon of Jewish blood is from my side, from my Polish half, though Leopold Bloom may be smiling in the background.

My reaction: that makes sense. Since I was a kid I have ended up with Jewish friends. My ex-wife and oldest son are Jewish. I’ve always loved modern Jewish literature and Yiddish writing in translation (I’m reading Shadows on the Hudson by Isaac Bashevis Singer.) In junior high school I read Martin Buber and Max I. Dimont’s Jews, God, and History (1962), looked into Spinoza for the first time and rooted for Israel during the Six-Day War. To this day, defending the U.S. and Israel are self-evident necessities. In 1967, after the Six-Day War, Jorge Luis Borges wrote “To Israel” (trans. Stephen Kessler, The Sonnets, 2010), and contemplated his own possible Jewish ancestry:

“Who’ll tell me whether you are in the lost
labyrinth of secular rivers in
my blood, Israel? Who can tell me where
my blood and your blood have flowed together?
It doesn’t matter. I know you are in a sacred
book that contains time and that rescues
red Adam’s story and the memory
and the agony of the Crucified.
You are in that book, which is the mirror
of every face that looks into its pages,
and of God’s face, who in his intricate
harsh crystal can be terribly divined.
Be safe, Israel, as you guard the wall
Of God in all the passion of your fight.”

Borges also devoted two poems to Spinoza and announced his intention to write a book titled Key to Spinoza. In a 1974 interview he said, “I am preparing a book on Spinoza's philosophy, because I have never understood him. He has always attracted me, less than Berkeley, less than Schopenhauer, but I cannot understand Spinoza.” Even so, when asked in 1979 to name his favorite historical character, Borges answered, “Spinoza, who committed his life to abstract thought.”

[Go here to read “Borges in Jerusalem” and here to read “Borges, the Jew.”]

Wednesday, November 14, 2012

`So That He Could Have It to Say'

It amounts to an adolescent game, a variation on the Robinson Crusoe fantasy, but proves itself useful in distinguishing the sustaining from the merely diverting: Marooned on an island, confined to a hospital bed, what books would you make certain to bring? Now let’s up the ante: What books or passages would you commit to memory, à la Fahrenheit 451, if you knew you would be denied access to printed matter? My first thought is poetry, more Shakespeare and Housman, for their music (itself a consolation) and graceful density of feeling and thought. In Bernard Malamud’s The Fixer (1966), Yakov Bok is imprisoned for the blood-libel murder of a Christian boy. The setting is Tsarist Russia in the early twentieth century. In prison, Bok is given strips of newspaper for wiping and is not permitted to read them, but does so surreptitiously. Malamud writes:

“During the endless empty days, to forget his misery a little, the fixer tried to remember things he had read. He remembered incidents from Spinoza’s life: how the Jews had cursed him in the synagogue; how an assassin had tried to kill him in the street, for his ideas; how he lived and died in his tiny room, studying, writing, grinding lenses for a living until his lungs had turned to glass.”

One thinks of Dr. Nahum Fischelson in Singer’s “The Spinoza of Market Street,” for whom Spinoza is a saintly figure, doubly an outsider, a reliable source of inspiration. But the inspiration for Bok gets him nowhere: 

“Necessity freed Spinoza and imprisoned Yakov. Spinoza thought himself into the universe but Yakov’s poor thoughts were inclosed in a cell.” 

Bok tries to remember what he studied of biology and history, and that too backfires: “They say God appeared in history and used it for his purposes, but if that was so he had no pity for men. God cried mercy and smote his chest, but there was no mercy because there was no pity.” He remembers scraps in Yiddish of stories by I.L. Peretz (1852-1915) and Sholem Aleichem (1859-1916), and some in Russian by Chekhov. Bok is an intelligent, thoughtful man but not well educated. He doesn’t think of himself as devout but neither is he a defiant unbeliever. Malamud said in an interview after he published The Fixer: "I am always interested in the irreligious man's unrelenting concern with God." Malamud writes of Bok:

“He recalled things from the Scriptures, in particular, fragments of psalms he had read in Hebrew on old parchment. He could, in a sense, smell the Psalms as well as hear them. They were sung weekly in the synagogue to glorify God and protect the shtetl from harm, which they never did. Yakov had chanted them, or heard them chanted, many times, and now in a period of remembrance he uttered verses, stanzas that he did not think he knew. He could not recall a whole psalm, but from fragments he put together one that he recited aloud in the in the cell in order not to forget it, so that he could have it to say.” 

Malamud reproduces Bok’s fragmentary memories of the Psalms, twenty-seven lines, a collage drawn mostly from the King James translation: 7:14-15, 6:6, 102:3-4, 35:11, 31:13, 10:12, 10:15, 21:9, 18:9, 18:14, 18:37. Their themes, from false accusation to retribution, comment on Bok’s plight. Many of us, Jews or not, locked up or free, hold in memory scraps of Psalms 23 and 100, and the speech in The Merchant of Venice in which Shylock emerges greater than the play that imprisons him.

Monday, February 03, 2020

'A Hell of a Lot of Wonderful Learning'

In the second volume of Questioning Minds: The Letters of Guy Davenport and Hugh Kenner (Counterpoint, 2018), Davenport writes to Kenner on June 10, 1968:

“The summer of 1949 Chris Middleton and I wandered around France and Italy, and had with us the Cantos and a volume of Donne. The upshot of that summer was that it dawned on me that a hell of a lot of wonderful learning never alluded to in my undergraduate education existed, and in a large way.”

Davenport later worked the anecdote into his obituary/tribute, “Ezra Pound, 1885-1972” (The Geography of the Imagination, 1981): “One fine summer Christopher Middleton and I walked about Italy and France with two books only, a Donne and a Cantos.” In 1949, Davenport was twenty-one, had graduated from Duke University and was a Rhodes Scholar at Merton College, Oxford. It’s natural for students to question the extent and worth of their formal education. For a polymath like Davenport, it was inevitable. I’ve become convinced that the function of education is to teach the means of self-education, to permit students to learn how to learn and become competent autodidacts.

One can question Davenport’s choice of Pound as a foundational text and the focus of much of his subsequent scholarship. Put that aside for now. Pound’s failings as man and writer are well-documented. I’m not guiltless on this count. There was a time in the nineteen-seventies when, briefly, I was nearly homeless and had lost access to most of my library. I salvaged three books: Spinoza’s Ethics, a complete Blake and Finnegans Wake. Today, I couldn’t return to Joyce’s hermetic farrago on a bet and can only sparingly read Blake (he was crazier than Cowper and Smart combined and at least as nuts as Pound). I still keep Spinoza handy.

In his essay “On Reading” (The Hunter Gracchus, 1996), Davenport recalls how he first became aware of style in writing while reading Hendrik Van Loon’s “whimsical history of the world” (presumably The Story of Mankind), which led him to Van Loon’s biography of Rembrandt, in which he first encountered the name of Baruch de Spinoza. That reference, in turn, sent him to Will Durant, who finally sent him directly to Spinoza’s work. Davenport writes:

“[A]ll fellow readers who have ever taken a book along to a humble restaurant will understand my saying that life has few enjoyments as stoical and pure as reading Spinoza’s Ethics, evening after evening, in a strange city – St. Louis, before I made friends there. The restaurant was Greek, cozy, comfortable, and for the neighborhood. The food was cheap, tasty, and filling.

“Over white beans with chopped onions, veal cutlet with a savory dressing, and eventually a fruit cobbler and coffee, I read the De Ethica in its Everyman edition, Draftech pen at the ready to underline passages I might want to refind easily later. Soul and mind were being fed together. I have not eaten alone in a restaurant in many years, but I see others doing it and envy them.”

Monday, November 12, 2007

`My Spiritual Mainstay'

In “Escape from Civilization,” written in 1972 and included in The Collected Stories (1983), the narrator, who sounds very much like a younger incarnation of the author, Isaac Bashevis Singer, wishes to flee the Lower East Side of Manhattan to live in the Sea Gate section of Brooklyn. He’s a romantic young man, born in Bilgoray, Poland (Singer’s mother’s home town), who first fled to Warsaw, then to the United States. He is an aspiring writer, well known enough to have his picture in a Yiddish newspaper. He withdraws his savings from the bank ($78) and packs his cardboard suitcase with his belongings:

“I carried a few books to be my spiritual mainstay while away from civilization: the Bible, Spinoza’s Ethics, Schopenhauer’s The World as Will and Idea, as well as a textbook with mathematical formulas. I was then an ardent Spinozist and, according to Spinoza, one can reach immortality only if one meditates upon adequate ideas, which means mathematics.”

I pay attention when people, real or fictional, distill their library to essentials, or play the old parlor game: Which books would you chose to take with you to a desert island? After all, what better reveals our values, our genuine priorities as opposed to social pretenses? While living in my college dormitory, I had two built-in shelves above my desk for books. I agonized over what to bring, what to leave home. In my sophomore year, I was certain the greatest novel ever written was The Wings of the Dove, but I owned the hefty two-volume New York Edition of James’ masterpiece. Bringing it meant slighting another title I couldn’t live without. I brought the James, however, even though I didn’t reread that year. I remember my relief when I found a diminutive hardback edition of Gulliver’s Travels (Oxford University Press, 1925 – I still have it), which could rest horizontally on top of other books, thus saving me precious shelf space.

I feel a kinship with Warshawsky, Singer’s narrator. He writes stories but carries no fiction on his comic odyssey to Brooklyn. Like so many Singer characters – I think of Dr. Nahum Fischelson, in “The Spinoza of Market Street” – Warshawsky is a high-minded sensualist, dwelling in the pure realm of Spinoza’s geometry while lusting after his newly divorced landlady. I share my love of books with Warshawsky, and my divided nature. As Dr. Fischelson says at the end of his story:

“Divine Spinoza, forgive me. I have become a fool.”

Wednesday, August 16, 2006

Two Reviewers

I trust and anticipate with pleasure the work of two book reviewers with steady newspaper gigs – Eric Ormsby at the New York Sun, and Joshua Cohen at the Jewish Daily Forward. Ormsby is a poet, critic, and scholar of Islam, and I have often praised him here. His reviews are models of wit and concision, his literary taste is impeccable, and his proclivity is to celebrate, not demean. In a recent piece about Thomas Gray, the 18th-century English poet who wrote the immortal “Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard," Ormsby said:

“Gray was an amateur in the original sense; he cultivated only what he loved. But in matters of mortality he was no amateur. Born in 1716, the fifth of 12 children, he was the only one to survive infancy; he too almost died from a fit but his mother grabbed a pair of scissors, slit open one of his veins, and saved him. When Richard West, his closest friend, died suddenly in 1742, Gray was bereaved and mourned him in verse for a decade. That grief nourished the great `Elegy.’”

What an admirable way to link a writer’s life and work, and what a powerful insight into a great poem many of us thought we knew. In a poem called “Garter Snake,” Ormsby describes the snake as “moving the way a chance felicity/silvers the whole attention of the mind.” For me, his poems and reviews are such “chance felicities.”

Cohen is a fiction writer, though I don’t know his work. In a recent review of Conversation With Spinoza: A Cobweb Novel, by Goce Smilevski, Cohen writes:

“I suspect that the current Spinoza obsession in America has much to do with our need to justify our secularism, in substantiating it as not just a modern dereliction but as an actual European creed, with history behind it, the bona fide of ages of thought on the nature of man’s relationship with God. Smilevski, being an Eastern European, seems to find in Spinoza a similar assurance brought to bear on a different concern: In a Godless Europe in which democracy was never native, it has become necessary to find a religious course that allows one to respect all creation without recourse to laws that necessarily issue from divinity as unified in one supreme intelligence.”

It’s news to me that the United States is in the grips of a “Spinoza obsession,” though that can only be good news. Cohen deftly links Spinoza, religion, politics and history, all in three well written sentences, and while I’m not certain I agree with him, he made me think and enjoy the process of evaluating his thoughts.

Much of the work of both writers is available online, though the Forward seems to have cleaned out its archives recently. Go here for Ormsby and here for Cohen.

Thursday, March 06, 2025

'Writers That Are Worth Anything Are Humorists'

Bertie Wooster has asked if he can purchase a gift for Jeeves while he is out, and the valet replies: “‘Well, sir, there has recently been published a new and authoritatively annotated edition of the works of the philosopher Spinoza. Since you are so generous, I would appreciate that very much.” This comes in the first chapter of Joy in the Morning, published by P.G. Wodehouse in 1947. I was reading it late the other night, alone in the front room, and I started giggling and my eyes watered. The dog looked concerned.

Ever since my nephew told me he had discovered Wodehouse and was going through his novels and stories like a guest at a party with an open bar, I’ve been reading Plum between more imposing volumes – including Spinoza, a thinker I discovered as a teenager thanks to a story by Isaac Bashevis Singer. (In another B&J confection, Carry On, Jeeves, Wodehouse has Jeeves say: “You would not enjoy Nietzsche, sir. He is fundamentally unsound.”) A reader tells me in a comment on Tuesday’s post that he is reading Wodehouse’s Something Fresh (1915):

“Every silly yet perfectly crafted page," he writes, "was a declaration of allegiance to something more enduring than even the greatest historical catastrophe -- the unexpected pleasure potential of just being alive. God bless the man – it’s a reminder I needed right now.”

An amusing scene with a clerk in a bookshop follows Jeeves’ request. While there, Bertie runs into Florence Craye, an intellectual woman to whom he was once engaged. “‘Bertie!’ she says, ‘This is amazing! Do you really read Spinoza?’”

Bertie, our narrator, thinks: “‘It’s extraordinary how one yields to that fatal temptation to swank. It undoes the best of us. Nothing, I mean, would have been simpler than to reply that she had got the data twisted and that the authoritatively annotated edition was a present for Jeeves. But, instead of doing the simple, manly, straightforward thing, I had to go and put on dog.” Bertie tells Florence:

“‘Oh, rather,’ I said, with an intellectual flick of the umbrella. ‘When I have a leisure moment, you will generally find me curled up with Spinoza’s latest.’”

Is there a moral component here, a lesson for all good readers? I suppose so. Don’t lie. Admit your shortcomings. But all of that is irrelevant. We laugh because all of us, at least on occasion, are tempted to put on airs so we appear smarter or better educated than we are. In effect, to lie.

I’m reminded of something Nabokov told an interviewer: “All writers that are worth anything are humorists.” This seems obvious to some of us. Much of the best humor implies a nuanced understanding of the world, the ability to see comedy in tragedy and vice versa – the essence of literary accomplishment. The humorless are earnest and dull and leave little room for a good laugh or an insight into human nature. “I’m not P.G. Wodehouse,” Nabokov continues. “I’m not a funny man, but give me an example of a great writer who is not a humorist. “

[Nabokov’s 1962 interview with Phyllis Meras for the Providence Sunday Journal is collected in Think, Write, Speak: Uncollected Essays, Reviews, Interviews and Letters to the Editor (eds. Brian Boyd and Anastasia Tolstoy, 2019).]

Saturday, December 03, 2022

'Those for Whom Our Affection is Personal'

“[T]he current of your admirable style floats pearls and diamonds.” 

Has one writer ever so charmingly praised another? Consider the odd appropriateness of the metaphor. In what sense is a prose style a current? And how can pearls and diamonds float? One thinks of the Mississippi River – “sullen, untamed and intractable,” in T.S. Eliot’s words. In this case, “sullen” clearly isn’t right, though the rest fits the relentless force of nature that was the tubercular Robert Louis Stevenson. In a brief life he mustered millions of words. After writing the sentence quoted above in his first letter to Stevenson, on December 5, 1884, Henry James continues: “The native gaiety of all that you write is delightful to me . . .”

 

Things between James and Stevenson didn’t start out so swimmingly. They first met at a lunch with Andrew Lang in 1879. In a letter to a friend, James described the Scot as “a shirt-collarless Bohemian and a great deal (in an inoffensive way) of a poseur.” In 1881, in a letter to W.E. Henley, Stevenson rather oddly described James’ Washington Square as “an unpleasant book.” The short novel is terribly sad and Stevenson could never have written anything like it, but that hardly makes it “unpleasant.”  He went on to describe James to Henley as “a mere club fizzle (fizzle perhaps too strong, on representations from the weaker vessel) and no out-of-doors, stand-up man whatever.” The sparring continued when James published “The Art of Fiction” (1884), in which he describes Treasure Island as “delightful." Stevenson, however, replied with “A Humble Remonstrance,” in which he objected to this statement by James: “The only reason for the existence of a novel is that it does compete with life.” In his letter James replies:

 

“[I have] a friendly desire to send you three words. Not words of discussion, dissent, retort or remonstrance, but of hearty sympathy, charged with the assurance of my enjoyment of everything you write. It’s a luxury, in this immoral age, to encounter some one who does write—who is really acquainted with that lovely art.”

 

Writers are a jealous, touchy bunch, as sensitive as adolescents with migraines. Stevenson possessed the rare gift of inspiring love and devotion in a vast, varied group of readers and writers. Consider the brief roll call of writers we think of as “lovable” – Spinoza, Chekhov, William James, Italo Svevo . . . who else, besides Stevenson? Eric Ormsby writes of him: “His outlook, in writing as in life, was robustly joyful, and this belief in the importance of joyfulness shaped his literary aesthetic.” And James says in his 1899 review of Stevenson’s Letters:

 

“It was the happy fortune of Robert Louis Stevenson to have created beyond any man of his craft in our day a body of readers inspired with the feelings that we for the most part place at the service only of those for whom our affection is personal.”

 

Stevenson died on this date, December 3, in 1894, at age forty-four (the same age as Thoreau, Chekhov, Hopkins, D.H. Lawrence, F. Scott Fitzgerald).


[A reader asks why I find Spinoza “loveable.” Borges gives a partial answer in his sonnet “Baruch Spinoza,” translated by Willis Barnstone:

 

“A haze of gold, the Occident lights up

The window. Now, the assiduous manuscript

Is waiting, weighed down with the infinite.

Someone is building God in a dark cup.

A man engenders God. He is a Jew

With saddened eyes and lemon-colored skin;

Time carries him the way a leaf, dropped in

A river, is borne off by waters to

Its end. No matter. The magician moved

Carves out his God with fine geometry;

From his disease, from nothing, he’s begun

To construct God, using the word. No one

Is granted such prodigious love as he:

The love that has no hope of being loved.”

 

Borges renders a sensitive understanding of Spinoza’s notion of amor intellectus Dei, and reminds how alone this young man was.]

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

`Soul and Mind'

Certain long-ago encounters with books, magazines and even newspapers carry with them, in memory, a sort of golden aura. One fondly recalls the work and the setting in which it was first enjoyed as “spots in time,” to use Wordsworth’s phrase, charged with an ineffable glow of pleasure. I remember, in 1985, reading Gary Giddins’ hommage to Jack Benny, “This Guy Wouldn’t Give You the Parsley Off His Fish,” in the journal Grand Street. It arrived in the mail and I took it with me to the late, lamented Third Street Cinema in Rensselaer, N.Y., and read it while waiting for the feature, Utu, to begin. I always loved Benny and Giddins’ essay is so beautifully written (it was included in his 1992 volume Faces in the Crowd), I was irritated when the film started to roll. To top it off, the movie was lousy.

I also remember reading Guy Davenport’s essay “On Reading” as it first appeared in the Fall 1987 issue of Antaeus. My oldest son was born that August, and that may have contributed to my heightened receptiveness to bliss. The journal had arrived in the mail and, for some reason, I was eating dinner alone in a Japanese restaurant housed in an A-frame structure resembling a ski lodge, just north of Albany, N.Y. Reading a favorite writer on reading is already pleasure doubled, but my pleasure unexpectedly quadrupled on Sunday when I reread the essay, collected in Davenport’s The Hunter Gracchus.

In the pertinent passage, Davenport recalls how he first became aware of style in writing while reading Hendrik Van Loon’s “whimsical history of the world” (presumably The Story of Mankind), which led him to Van Loon’s biography of Rembrandt, in which he first encountered the name of Baruch de Spinoza. That reference, in turn, sent him to Will Durant, who finally sent him directly to Spinoza’s work. Davenport picks it up at that point:

“…and all fellow readers who have ever taken a book along to a humble restaurant will understand my saying that life has few enjoyments as stoical and pure as reading Spinoza’s Ethics, evening after evening, in a strange city – St. Louis, before I made friends there. The restaurant was Greek, cozy, comfortable, and for the neighborhood. The food was cheap, tasty, and filling.

“Over white beans with chopped onions, veal cutlet with a savory dressing, and eventually a fruit cobbler and coffee, I read the De Ethica in its Everyman edition, Draftech pen at the ready to underline passages I might want to refind easily later. Soul and mind were being fed together. I have not eaten alone in a restaurant in many years, but I see others doing it and envy them.”

That’s the quadrupling I mentioned: Rereading an essay by a favorite writer writing about reading a favorite book (his, mine) for the first time in a restaurant, that I first read in another restaurant. That’s convoluted but the pleasure is simple and intense.

I have a dim recollection of first reading Spinoza on West 25th Street in Cleveland, seated on a CTS bus, but no golden glow is attached to it. Like Guy, I seldom eat alone in restaurants anymore, but restaurants are the setting for several bookish memories:

Reading Henry Fielding’s Tom Jones for the first time in a Greek restaurant in a Bowling Green, Ohio, strip mall; Raymond Sokolov’s life of A.J. Liebling in a Rax roast-beef-sandwich joint in Richmond, Ind.; and Jack Fruchtman’s life of Thomas Paine in an Indian restaurant in Schenectady, N.Y.

Interesting that Guy writes “Soul and mind were being fed together,” not “body and soul.”

Saturday, July 29, 2006

Spinoza Redux

Thanks to Dave Lull for a link to a piece in today's New York Times by Rebecca Goldstein, author of Betraying Spinoza: The Renegade Jew Who Gave Us Modernity. The occasion was the 350th anniversary, on Thursday, of Spinoza's excommunication.

Saturday, October 06, 2018

'We Live in a Fanatical Age'

Even wise men can be viciously wrong in their prejudices. I admire much of George Santayana’s prose and thought without reservation, though he was an inexcusably stupid anti-Semite. When Richard John Neuhaus reviewed the reissue of John McCormick’s biography of the philosopher in 2005, he wrote: “What is admired in Santayana is disturbingly entangled with what is repugnant.” That makes him impossible for today’s literary Manicheans to understand or admire (of course, many of those same Manicheans are already anti-Semitic). People are complicated, more than we can hope to fathom. Let’s go further and say we will always remain mysteries to each other and ourselves. As soon as we claim to comprehensively understand another human being, we’re lying. I’m reading Santayana’s letters. Here’s a passage, written to Daniel Cory in the year of the Anschluss, Munich and Kristallnacht, that prompted these thoughts:

“We live in a fanatical age, an age of propaganda, when everybody wants the support of the whole herd in order to be quite at peace in his own conscience. I am reading the Upanishads, St. Augustine’s Confessions, and Spinoza’s Politics, to take the bad taste out of my mouth.”

Spinoza, of course, was a Jew. Parallels between 1938 and 2018 will be apparent to most conscious readers. Yet, just two years earlier, on Aug. 12, 1936, Santayana wrote to George Sturgis: “The Jews, for instance, aren’t in the least like Abraham or King Solomon: they are just sheenies.”