Thursday, November 19, 2026

'You Reveled in Your Craft'

The late Canadian poet Daryl Hine writes in “A Visit” (Recollected Poems 1951-2004):

“Poets must have something else to write of

Than their own tragic thoughts and epic feelings.”

 

Hine was writing in 1967, during the “confessional” heyday and long after the triumph of free verse over meter, rhyme and traditional forms. Poetic wannabes with little love of language and no gift for it were free to spill their narcissistic guts. Readers are still paying the price. Good poets, not to mention great ones, are nearly as extinct as passenger pigeons. Consider this year’s Nobel Laureate for Literature.

 

You can’t say they flourish but some exceptions thrive in their poetic game preserves. Arguably, the last great poet in English was Philip Larkin (if not J.V. Cunningham or Richard Wilbur). When I learned of Larkin’s death on December 2, 1985, I was in Albany, N.Y., sitting in the office used by reporters in the Albany County Courthouse, furnished with a table, two chairs, two computers and a file cabinet. The cast-iron radiators banged. The floor was made of uneven planks, and the room was narrow, like a long closet. The ceiling was high, fitted with a strip of fluorescent bulbs. The room was always dim and overheated. I read Larkin’s obituary in the New York Times – news of “nothing more terrible, nothing more true,” as Larkin had put it.

 

Within a month, Clive James, another good poet, published “A Valediction for Philip Larkin” in the London Review of Books. Here is the first of its thirty-three five-line stanzas:

 

“You never traveled much but now you have,

Into the land whose brochures you like least:

That drear Bulgaria beyond the grave

Where wonders have definitely ceased –

Ranked as a dead loss even in the East.”

 

James was in Kenya when he heard the news. Much of his poem is African travelogue, but eventually he returns to Larkin:

 

“Forgive me, but I hardly felt a trace

Of grief. Just sudden fear your being dead

So soon had left us disinherited.”

 

The carrion-eaters moved in quickly. Larkin’s death widened the distance between us and the tradition, receding in time, of Auden, Hardy, Housman and Wordsworth. When a voice of plainspoken eloquence is silenced, frauds grow emboldened. Larkin’s leaving leaves us more vulnerable to the calculating and their naïve followers. James rightly honors Larkin’s clarity and craft:

 

“The truth is that you reveled in your craft.

Profound glee charged your sentences with wit.

You beat them into stanza form and laughed:

They didn’t sound like poetry one bit,

Except for being absolutely it.”

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

'Age Interests Me More Than Youth'

As a kid, if I had a choice, I’d prefer the company of adults to my contemporaries. Not my parents, certainly, and not their friends. They were angry drunks and tellers of dull stories. At parties, one of my father’s buddies, a cop, liked inviting us over to where he was seated and flicking whiskey into our eyes. Another kept a tube of kidney stones in his pocket. He would rattle them and assure us we would get them too. 

I liked old people. Somehow they seemed trustworthy. It didn’t bother me that they were often slow and didn’t know the things we knew (which wasn’t much). This preference carried over into my professional life. As a newspaper reporter I looked forward every December to interviewing Pearl Harbor survivors. Once in a retirement home, I interviewed a dozen or more elderly Jews who had emigrated from the former Soviet Union. I liked the sense that some old people seemed suffused with history.

 

I recently turned seventy-four and work hard not to bore young people. I don’t know what it means to be old. I can describe physical and emotional changes, but that misses the point. Consider “It Is,” a poem by C.H. Sisson in Anchises (1976). That’s the year he turned sixty-two, not yet elderly:

 

“It is extraordinary how old age

Creeps on one

First it is not believed, even noticed

Then one notices symptoms but says nothing:

At the last nothing is what one says.”

 

Half a life we spend immune to age, and the other half denying its inevitability. Sisson’s choice of “symptoms” is precise if we think of aging as disease, as though a cure were possible (or desirable). At forty I got bifocals and a diagnosis of hypertension. Now, more than thirty years later, I have arthritis and low blood pressure, and I count myself fortunate. Our exploration of this strange new country – age – is unprecedented, or so it seems to us. Sisson’s poem is a dispatch from a scout reporting the lay of the land ahead.

 

I returned to Sisson after reading a Substack essay by the poet John Talbot, who describes him as “one of those poets we ought not leave behind.” This in turn reminded me of the interview Mike Juster conducted with Talbot in in 2024:

 

“Age interests me more than youth—it always has. I’ve always felt a strong inclination to look backwards for the truth. In my naïve worldview, old people, old books, old languages are closer to the origin of things, where the truth of things, including love, is most likely to be encountered. I feel myself on the brink of a gulf that separates me from friends for whom all answers lie in the future, and who feel things getting better and better in proportion as we jettison the encumbrances of the past. My imagination inclines to tradition, restoration, and innovation rather than rupture and novelty.”

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

'(The Writing’s Rather Good.)'

Kingsley Amis lived up to one of his own favorite adages: “Any proper writer ought to be able to write anything, from an Easter Day sermon to a sheep-dip handout.” For more than forty years he reliably churned out novels, poems, criticism, the sheerest pen-for-hire journalism, you name it. I concur. If you can write well, with some facility and with some grasp of various form, you can turn your gifts to anything, perhaps without humiliating yourself. 

Timothy Steele contributes two poems to the Fall/Winter edition of Light, the journal of light verse. Steele is a living master of traditional formal verse and of scholarship defending it. One thinks of him as a “serious” poet. His poems are never tawdry or cheap. When I read Steele, I expect to learn something, whether insights into prosody or the folkways of California. For these reasons, seeing his work in a journal dedicated to light verse comes as a surprise. It shouldn’t (T.S. Eliot wrote light verse) but it does.

 

The first poem is “Re-gifting as a Problem in Quantum Mechanics”:

 

“With Christmas coming, friends re-gift to us

A box of pastries with a tartan bow.

They’re dieting and feeling generous:

The treats have sugar, cream, and filo dough.

 

“Though pained, we view the case as relative.

Our friends behave, we say, like light behaves:

They simultaneously receive and give,

As light acts both as particles and waves.

 

“The pastries, too, present a paradox.

They’re kin to Schrödinger’s dead/living cat.

Until—unless—we open up the box,

We can’t say that their state is this or that.

 

“They might be flaky or as dense as paste.

They might be finger food or call for forks.

We might, experimentally nibbling, taste

The flavors of their leptons and their quarks.

 

“To re-re-gift them would be inhumane.

They’ve been rejected once; rejection hurts.

If we digest them, they might help us gain

A unified field theory of desserts.

 

“Best lift the lid and see the problem through.

The same laws govern physics and nutrition:

You cannot have your cake and eat it, too,

Or gauge both its momentum and position.

 

“Best welcome any gift that causes thought

(Which travels faster than the speed of light)

About the mysteries of matter, not

To mention those of human appetite.”

 

A smattering of knowledge about quantum physics and the big names in the field – Planck, Einstein, Heisenberg, Schrödinger – is helpful but not required. “The flavors of their leptons and their quarks” is especially good. Both are elementary particles. Murray Gell-man took the name “quark” from Finnegans Wake: “Three Quarks for Muster Mark!”

 

The second Steele poem is “War and Peace”:

 

“Peace is boring, war is hell.”

André is clobbered by a shell.

Natasha—grieving, in despair—

Weds waiting-in-the-wings Pierre

And is fulfilled by motherhood.

The End. (The writing’s rather good.)”

 

This reads like the book review of an intelligent but lazy sixth-grader.

Monday, November 16, 2026

'It Cannot Be Said That He Was a Great Poet'

 Years ago, when first reading Dr. Johnson’s Lives of the Most Eminent English Poets (1779–81), I was irritated by his inclusion of obscure, minor poets even he judged mediocre (albeit, usually, politely). Today I welcome the presence of the Thomases, Tickell and Sprat, for instance, who occasionally shine in a line or two and tell us something about the poetic tastes of their time. Imagine in 250 years reading a comparable book, which of necessity would include J.V. Cunningham and Richard Wilbur, but also such nullities as Mary Oliver and Gary Snyder. It would tell us something about the sad decline of our literary age and permit us to feel superior in our judgments. 

Let’s look at Johnson on William Broome, born in Bromsgrove (where Geoffrey Hill was born in 1932) in 1689 and educated at Cambridge. He entered the Church and served as rector. Johnson writes: “. . . I have formerly heard him described as a contracted scholar and a mere versifier, unacquainted with life, and unskilful in conversation. His addiction to metre was then such, that his companions familiarly called him poet. When he had opportunities of mingling with mankind, he cleared himself.”

 

This makes Broome sound awkward and inept in the social world, but he went on to translate The Iliad into prose and assisted Alexander Pope in his translation of the same poem. Broome and others went on to co-translate The Odyssey with Pope. Of Broome’s own verse Johnson writes:

 

“[T]hough it cannot be said that he was a great poet, it would be unjust to deny that he was an excellent versifier; his lines are smooth and sonorous, and his diction is select and elegant. His rhymes are sometimes unsuitable; in his Melancholy, he makes breath rhyme to birth in one place, and to earth in another. Those faults occur but seldom; and he had such power of words and numbers as fitted him for translation; but, in his original works, recollection seems to have been his business more than invention.”

 

Here are lines from Broome’s “Melancholy: An Ode, Occasion’d by the Death of a Beloved Daughter, 1723”:

 

“Adieu vain Mirth, and noisy Joys!

Ye gay Desires, deluding Toys!

Thou thoughtful Melancholy deign

To hide me in thy pensive Train!”

 

Broome died on this date, November 16, in 1745 at age fifty-five or fifty-six.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

'Gasping, Staggering, Stammering Tom Fool '

I fancy myself the mild-mannered sort but I enjoy vituperation in others, especially if it’s caustic, unfair and articulate, and you can almost see the spit flying. The master of this mode in literature is Thomas Carlyle. An old-fashioned word comes to mind when describing him: churlish. Consider this from a November 2, 1831, entry in his Notebooks. It makes me laugh every time I read it: 

“Charles Lamb I sincerely believe to be in some considerable degree insane. A more pitiful, ricketty, gasping, staggering, stammering Tom fool I do not know. He is witty by denying truisms, and abjuring good manners. His speech wriggles hither and thither with an incessant painful fluctuation; not an opinion in it or a fact or even a phrase that you can thank him for: more like a convulsion fit than natural systole and diastole. Besides he is now a confirmed shameless drunkard: asks vehemently for gin-and-water in strangers' houses; tipples until he is utterly mad, and is only not thrown out of doors because he is too much despised for taking such trouble with him. Poor Lamb! Poor England where such a despicable abortion is named genius!”

 

Carlyle’s verbal convulsion works because you don’t have to agree with him (I don’t) while admiring his mental dexterity. He was a masterful writer of prose. Angry people too often sputter and substitute obscenities for vitriol. The best put-downs are funny, intentionally or otherwise.

 

One can hardly imagine two specimens of Homo sapiens less compatible than Lamb and Carlyle, though I love them both. Carlyle turned sputtering rage into an art form, while Lamb boasted: “Anything awful makes me laugh.” On another occasion, Carlyle referred to Lamb and his mentally ill sister Mary as “a very sorry pair of phenomena” and characterized Charles’ conversation as “diluted insanity” and the man himself as an “emblem of imbecility bodily and spiritually.”

Saturday, November 14, 2026

'Little or No True Value'

Just as songs and commercial jingles randomly enter my consciousness, without me having heard them, some dating back sixty years or more, so too do words. Friday’s irritant was flummery. I thought I might have remembered it from Shakespeare but I was wrong. I vaguely recalled that it meant nonsense, bloviation, bullshit. That led me to check H.L. Mencken. It would seem to have been coined for him. I found it. In Prejudices: Fourth Series (1924), describing Rotary (a frequent Mencken target) and other civic and fraternal organizations, and the titles, rituals, and costumes members wear, he refers to “self-deceptive flummery.” He uses it several other times.

Next I checked the OED. It has an unlikely origin and entered English early in the seventeenth century from the Welsh. It meant: “A dish made by soaking ground oats or other grains in water and then boiling them to form a gelatinous semi-solid porridge.” You can hear the modern metaphorical meaning bubbling. In the following century, it came to mean something a little more appetizing:

“Any of various sweet dishes having a soft, gelatinous consistency; . . . a dish resembling a custard or blancmange, made with milk or cream, eggs, and sugar, and sometimes shaped in a mould.”

Almost simultaneously, the word moved closer to the modern meaning: “Speech or behaviour considered as having little or no true value; nonsense; . . . insincere praise; empty flattery; (now frequently) meaningless and often ostentatious or extravagant behaviour or display.” Authors cited include Walter Scott, Thackeray, and Thomas Hardy.

I dare you to find a more useful, reasonably polite word to describe today’s cant-filled politics, most writing, advertising, and even casual conversation.

Friday, November 13, 2026

'The Gift of Reading'

From A Sunday of Liberty I’ve learned that the kindergarten has been in an uproar again. This time it’s over that eternally debated question: can someone read thirty books in a year? First reaction: who cares? Second reaction: what books are we talking about? Third: what do we mean by “read”? For the moment, let’s pretend we care. I think Robert Louis Stevenson covered this nicely in Essays in the Art of Writing: 

“The gift of reading, as I have called it, is not very common, nor very generally understood.  It consists, first of all, in a vast intellectual endowment - a free grace, I find I must call it - by which a man rises to understand that he is not punctually right, nor those from whom he differs absolutely wrong.”

 

My sense is that passionate reading is extraordinarily rare. A man or woman can be that sort of reader by reading one book a year, if that book is St. Augustine’s Confessions or Spinoza’s Ethics. Or, at another level, Montaigne’s Essays or Guy Davenport’s The Geography of the Imagination. Absorbing it, arguing with the author, letting his words change your life. Such volumes carry the imprimatur of previous generations. There’s a reason for that. The truest critic is time. Many people, I think, read solely for evidence that the opinions they already hold are being confirmed. The best kind of reading can make you vulnerable and moves you to question yourself. In other words, it’s not the quantity of books, it’s quality. And I haven't even mentioned the books we read and reread across a lifetime.

 

 Stevenson was born on this date, November 13, in 1850, and died in 1894 at age forty-four.