“To listen to the voice of poetry is to enjoy, not a victory, but a momentary release, a brief enchantment. And perhaps, obliquely, it is to enjoy something more. Having an ear ready for the voice of poetry is to be disposed to choose delight rather than pleasure or virtue or knowledge, a disposition which will reflect itself in practical life in an affection for its intimations of poetry.”
By “poetry” I take Michael
Oakeshott in “The Voice of Poetry in the Conversation Mankind” (1959) to
suggest not merely verse but any aesthetic experience. I thought of Oakeshott’s
passage again while listening to Aaron Copland’s “Quiet City.” I was introduced
to this piece many years ago by my brother. The late Terry Teachout was an
admirer. He said it was characterized by a “controlled yet intensely melancholy
lyricism.” Terry called it “masterly.”
For some, a love of poetry,
the best of it, heightens awareness of the beauty and the pleasing symmetry of
life. Our senses transcend the merely utilitarian. There’s more to life than raising
children and going to work, though such activities can help us “choose
delight” when performing the routinely pragmatic. The voice of poetry is not dreamy or
self-consciously “poetic.” Oakeshott continues:
“Nevertheless, we must
expect to listen for this voice more often than we hear it. Poetic imagining
has frequently been recognized as a ‘visitation’; but while this has been taken
as an emblem of its superior status, even of its divine inspiration, properly
understood it is testimony only of the unavoidable transience of contemplative
activity.”
No one is permanently
poetic, not even Dante or Alexander Pope. To pretend otherwise is to endorse an
adolescent, lavender-scented understanding of the “artist.” In a word, decadence. Oakeshott next quotes a poem without identifying its author:
“All things can tempt me
from this craft of verse:
One time it was a woman’s
face, or worse --
The seeming needs of my
fool-driven land;
Now nothing but comes
readier to the hand
Than this accustomed toil.
When I was young,
I had not given a penny
for a song
Did not the poet sing it
with such airs
That one believed he had a
sword upstairs;
Yet would be now, could I
but have my wish,
Colder and dumber and
deafer than a fish.”
It’s Yeats, of course, carefully chosen by Oakeshott. It was collected in Responsibilities (1918), his first volume of poems, as a volume, that might fairly be judged a masterpiece. Yeats showed us he had matured and left the “Celtic Twilight” behind him. Poetry is “accustomed toil” and we are its beneficiaries. Oakeshott closes his essay with these beautiful lines, poetic in their own right:
“But it is a wish that can
have only an intermittent fulfilment. In short, there is no vita
contemplativa; there are only moments of contemplative activity abstracted
and rescued from the flow of curiosity and contrivance. Poetry is a sort of
truancy, a dream within the dream of life, a wild flower planted among our
wheat.”
[“The Voice of Poetry in
the Conversation of Mankind” is collected in Oakeshott’s Rationalism in
Politics and Other Essays (1962; rev. 1991).]