Tuesday, July 08, 2025

'It Is Always Summer, Always the Golden Hour'

I fight the urge to wallow in nostalgia but it seeps back in like moisture in an unfinished basement. I take that image from my childhood home. The walls and floor were bare concrete. Stacks of newspaper and lumber felt flesh-like with dampness. Down there it was always chilly, even in summer.

The poet Jane Greer is seventy-two and lives in North Dakota. For twelve years she edited the Plains Poetry Journal. She is a poet of domesticity and technical rigor, Midwestern in her good-humored seriousness, a Roman Catholic who reveres the wonder of creation. I’m from Ohio, a semi-Midwestern state, but there’s nothing homogenous about the Midwest and its people. She’s rural, I’m urban/suburban. Most of the stereotypes don’t hold, though Midwesterners indulge them and laugh. I remember being surprised when a buddy and I got lost in Illinois trying to outrun a tornado that never happened. We found ourselves in Lewiston, where Edgar Lee Masters moved with his family at age twelve. It served as his model for Spoon River. And the surrounding fields of corn felt almost claustrophobic.

 

I read Those Days: An American Album By Richard Critchfield (1931-94) when it was published in 1986. Like Greer, Critchfield was a North Dakota native, and the book recounts his family’s history in that state and Iowa. I remember associating it with Willa Cather and Wright Morris. Greer, I discovered, reviewed the book in the April 1987 issue of Chronicles, and it begins with a passage any writer would be delighted to hear:

 

“This is a book I wish I’d written, a love story of the largest and best kind. Like most people, I remember my childhood, that eternal summer, in a glow of happy forgetfulness, simply out of pleasure. Richard Critchfield ‘remembers,’ as if he had been there, his parents' lives and society before he was born, and shows why it’s important to remember and to go back even further than our own birth: Because like it or not, we are attached. We are not historyless like Adam, breathed out of nothing; we’re drawn from the narrow end of a real and compelling vortex—history—vivid with blood and bone, passion and fear, as it touches down to make us in the here and now. Part of everything that was and will be, we move up the funnel of history to make room for those whose history we will be.”

 

I envy Critchfield’s reconstruction of his family’s history, in part because most of mine is a blank. I know almost nothing about my father’s family and only unconnected shards about my mother’s. These people didn’t talk about the past, whether out of guilt or abject indifference, and bequeathed little living memory to their descendants. I’m left with all the questions I didn’t ask.

 

“This is no vague nostalgic trek back to the nonexistent ‘good old days,’” Greer writes, “or mere homage to a loved mother, but a gifted writer’s careful examination of all available resources, to reconstruct the rhythm and immediacy of the past—its sounds and smells, human passions and disappointments. Critchfield has resuscitated those days, given them breath and pulse, and made their relevance to us, now, evident.”

 

Here is “The Light As Thick As Clover Honey,” the first poem in Greer’s third collection, The World as We Know It Is Falling Away (Lambing Press, 2022):

 

‘Here is the square pink house on the green street.

Here is the long back yard sloped to the alley.

Here is the rusty swing, and here is the pup-tent

bleaching the grass. Here is the happy family

like all the others. Here is the sunburnt child

on her blue bike whose streamers are the reins

of a great stallion; here they gallop the world

from home to grandmother’s and home again

on odd brick streets, around the painted bandstand,

through the gap in in the church’s high trimmed hedge.

Here is the small town hugging the river bend,

cicadas rasping out their alien urge,

the light as thick as clover honey. Here

it is always summer, always the golden hour.”


“Eternal summer” in the review, “it is always summer” in Greer’s poem.

2 comments:

Wurmbrand said...

To those who have elderly parents still alive and coherent, I suggest that (if you haven't done so already) you get them talking about things they remember and that you will want to know about after they're gone. Happily for me, I read a book of reminiscences by a guy from our old neighborhood in Coos Bay, Oregon, and that, I think, prompted me to purposefully talk with Mom and Dad and get a lot of memories before it was too late -- although I still think of things I wish I'd asked. The sad thing is that, for a lot of us, when we were kids we would have become restless quickly if our parents had started talking about their old days, things we wish now we'd known and had written down.

Marly Youmans said...

So glad that you wrote about Jane's work... lovely piece.