Tuesday, November 17, 2026

'(The Writing’s Rather Good.)'

Kingsley Amis lived up to one of his own favorite adages: “Any proper writer ought to be able to write anything, from an Easter Day sermon to a sheep-dip handout.” For more than forty years he reliably churned out novels, poems, criticism, the sheerest pen-for-hire journalism, you name it. I concur. If you can write well, with some facility and with some grasp of various form, you can turn your gifts to anything, perhaps without humiliating yourself. 

Timothy Steele contributes two poems to the Fall/Winter edition of Light, the journal of light verse. Steele is a living master of traditional formal verse and of scholarship defending it. One thinks of him as a “serious” poet. His poems are never tawdry or cheap. When I read Steele, I expect to learn something, whether insights into prosody or the folkways of California. For these reasons, seeing his work in a journal dedicated to light verse comes as a surprise. It shouldn’t (T.S. Eliot wrote light verse) but it does.

 

The first poem is “Re-gifting as a Problem in Quantum Mechanics”:

 

“With Christmas coming, friends re-gift to us

A box of pastries with a tartan bow.

They’re dieting and feeling generous:

The treats have sugar, cream, and filo dough.

 

“Though pained, we view the case as relative.

Our friends behave, we say, like light behaves:

They simultaneously receive and give,

As light acts both as particles and waves.

 

“The pastries, too, present a paradox.

They’re kin to Schrödinger’s dead/living cat.

Until—unless—we open up the box,

We can’t say that their state is this or that.

 

“They might be flaky or as dense as paste.

They might be finger food or call for forks.

We might, experimentally nibbling, taste

The flavors of their leptons and their quarks.

 

“To re-re-gift them would be inhumane.

They’ve been rejected once; rejection hurts.

If we digest them, they might help us gain

A unified field theory of desserts.

 

“Best lift the lid and see the problem through.

The same laws govern physics and nutrition:

You cannot have your cake and eat it, too,

Or gauge both its momentum and position.

 

“Best welcome any gift that causes thought

(Which travels faster than the speed of light)

About the mysteries of matter, not

To mention those of human appetite.”

 

A smattering of knowledge about quantum physics and the big names in the field – Planck, Einstein, Heisenberg, Schrödinger – is helpful but not required. “The flavors of their leptons and their quarks” is especially good. Both are elementary particles. Murray Gell-man took the name “quark” from Finnegans Wake: “Three Quarks for Muster Mark!”

 

The second Steele poem is “War and Peace”:

 

“Peace is boring, war is hell.”

André is clobbered by a shell.

Natasha—grieving, in despair—

Weds waiting-in-the-wings Pierre

And is fulfilled by motherhood.

The End. (The writing’s rather good.)”

 

This reads like the book review of an intelligent but lazy sixth-grader.

No comments: