Rare is the poet who can
simultaneously think and sing. C.H. Sisson once quoted the French critic Charles
Maurras saying, “Reason
may convince, but it is rhythm that persuades.” Prose writers don’t talk much
about the rhythms of their words, which is probably a good thing. Prose is the
draft horse of style, getting the heavy job done. Too much filigree and the
language turns precious. The reader rightly suspects the writer is compensating
for sparsity of content (e.g., John Updike).
Words are never in
isolation and are more like notation in a musical score than stones in a
mosaic. One word follows another according to the logic of sound and sense. We
spend a lot of time matching words to the rhythm that already exists in our
heads, a rhythm we can’t begin to perceive until we start arranging the words.
Sometimes for emphasis we purposely break the rhythm, always with resolution or
absence of resolution in mind.
Much of the poetry written
in the last century and a quarter is indistinguishable from prose – often tone-deaf
prose. No need to name names. A writer who wrote superior prose and poetry, a
rare feat of juggling, is Janet Lewis. Consider “Carmel Highlands” (Selected
Poems of Janet Lewis, ed. R.L. Barth, 2000):
“Below the gardens and the
darkening pines
The living water sinks
among the stones,
Sinking yet foaming till
the snowy tones
Merge with the fog drawn
landward in dim lines.
The cloud dissolves among
the flowering vines,
And now the definite
mountain-side disowns
The fluid world, the
immeasurable zones.
Then white oblivion
swallows all designs.
“But still the rich
confusion of the sea,
Unceasing voice, sombre
and solacing,
Rises through veils of
silence past the trees;
In restless repetition
bound, yet free,
Wave after wave in deluge
fresh releasing
An ancient speech, hushed
in tremendous ease.”
The words float like
leaves in the currents of a river. There’s no hurry, no rush to the finish, but
the lines are suffused with a steady, uninsistent sense of momentum. Throughout
the seventy years of Lewis’ writing life, she wrote poems in both form and free verse. She is a writer seriously in need of rediscovery. One of her
novels, The Wife of Martin Guerre (1941), is among the four or five
finest ever written by an American. Here is a 1945 poem, “Lines with a Gift of
Herbs”:
“The summer's residue
In aromatic leaf,
Shrunken and dry, yet true
In fragrance, their
belief,
“These from the hard earth
drew
Essence of rosemary,
Of lavender, faintly blue,
While unconfused nearby
“From the same earth
distilled
Grey sage and savory,
Each one distinctly
willed,
Stoic morality.
“The Emperor said: ‘Though
all
Conspire to break thy
will,
Clear stone, thou emerald,
shall
Be ever emerald still.’
“And these, small,
unobserved,
Through summer chemistry,
Have all their might
conserved
In treasure, finally.”
“The Emperor” is Marcus
Aurelius in Meditations (trans. Maxwell Staniforth): “Whatever the world
may say or do, my part is to keep myself good; just as a gold piece, or an
emerald, or a purple robe insists perpetually, ‘Whatever the world may say or
do, my part is to remain an emerald and keep my color true.’” The passage
suggests Lewis’ courage and steadfastness, her “Stoic morality.” Here is a 1941
poem she wrote after the death of a friend and fellow novelist, “For Elizabeth
Madox Roberts”:
“From the confusion of
estranging years,
The imperfections of the
changing heart,
This hour leaves only
tears;
Tears, and my earliest
love, Elizabeth, and changeless art.”
Lewis, in her fiction and
verse, is one of the few essential American writers of the last century, along
with Cather, Nabokov and her husband, Yvor Winters. Lewis was born on this
date, August 17, in 1899 and died in 1998 at ninety-nine.